subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Fri, Jul 25 2008 

Published May 14, 2008 09:01 pm - A Minnesota school district went too far when it required students to stand during the Pledge of Allegiance.

Our View: Encourage, but don't force, respect for Pledge


The Free Press

A heads-up for public school districts: You may want to dust off your student handbooks and reread Pledge of Allegiance rules. It could avoid some embarrassing legal contortions at some point.

Last week three eighth-graders at Dilworth-Glyndon-Felton Junior High were suspended for refusing to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Controversy inevitably followed, and the school’s principal quickly announced that school officials were re-evaluating the policy.

The school’s policy had said that although students are not required to recite the Pledge, they are nevertheless compelled to stand as a signal of respect. The students, themselves, explained they do not disrespect the nature of the Pledge, but they do disagree with a policy that some would argue forces a belief system onto others. A good lawyer would argue that forcing compliance with such a policy prevents students’ right to symbolic expression.

In other words, the act of standing during the Pledge, to some, conveys the message that the Pledge is endorsed when, in fact, it might not be.

School rules on topics such as these are always accompanied by strong emotions. It is always difficult to pinpoint how free speech rights should be enforced with minors. Students, obviously, do not get to make the rules in their schools, because the responsibility of their education rests with adults. Schools, after all, exist to teach important lessons, and a patriotic respect for the principles in which this nation was founded upon ought to be available as part of the learning experience. The Pledge of Allegiance reminds students of their rights and responsibilities in this democratic society. But the Pledge shouldn’t be mandated, and isn’t, by law.

What apparently inspired some of the students in this case was the principle that individual conscience dictates the freedom to stand or not to stand. People disagree on the constitutionality of Pledge rules in school settings, and indeed the case can be made that Pledge violators poison proper school atmosphere.

Still, it would be rare, indeed, for any public school district to want to press the issue. Dilworth-Glyndon-Felton’s Pledge rule, while attempting to walk a middle line, tends to invite disrespect rather than encourage it — provided there are those who wish to press the point.



print this story    email this story   

Click here to load this Caspio Bridge DataPage.
Click here to load this Caspio Bridge DataPage.




monster
wheels

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Top Jobs

DOTSON COMPANY INC
Industrial Maintenance Technician

Minnesota¹s most technologically advanced foundry is looking for a highly t
...>MORE

NEW HORIZON - DIRECT SUPPORT PROFESSIONALS
Direct Support Professionals, Elysian. Prefer exp¹d individuals that have worked with DD, TBI, & MI adults. hourly wage ...>MORE

MANKATO FORD EMPLOYEMENT OPPORTUNITY
Employment Opportunity
Automotive Technician
Positions open immediately for experienced Technician.
Manka
...>MORE

MN ELEVATOR
Machine Operator

Minnesota Elevator, Inc. (MEI) is accepting applications for two Machine Operator openings o
...>MORE

LAGERS Chrysler World
Lager's Chrysler World

Parts Counter Sales
...>MORE

See all ads

Top Auto/Recreation

1997 DODGE 1500
1997 Dodge 1500 4x4, ext cab, 129k, 6' lift, off road tires, dual exhaust, bed liner, AC, $4500/obo 507-464-3350...>MORE

Lager's Chrysler World •Mankato
LagersChryslerWorld
Browse South Central Minnes
...>MORE

See all ads

Top Real Estate/Rental

St. Croix River Property
in Prescott, WI Cabin 600 sq ft. w/200ft shoreline
on 3.3 ac., w/potential bldg sites. Contact attorney Leo Beskar
...>MORE

Spacious Apartments that you can afford all over town
Atwood Property Management Inc.
507-388-9375
Serving the Community for 70 years
>MORE

BEAUTIFUL RAVINE LOT
4 bedrooms, 3 bath home on fantastic 2.5 acre wooded ravine. Large game room, family room, fireplace, sun room, hot tub ...>MORE

18 Cardinal Ct, N Mkto
18 Cardinal Ct, N Mkto
Pre Realtor Price of $359,900 - SAVE $15,000
5BR, 3BA, 4200+sf
Huge kitchen w/ hr
...>MORE

NEW HOUSE FOR SALE: Lake Cochrane, SD
Golf Course & Lake Home
3,000 square foot home, 881 square foot garage
Golf Cart Door, 2nd basement stairs to
...>MORE

See all ads

Top Deals of the Day

The Free Press Classified Marketplace
Place your Top Deal of the Day
Contact Roxanne or Lee today!
classified@mankatofreepress.com
507-
...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

rc