subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Tue, Oct 07 2008 

Published June 17, 2007 12:08 am - The next round of labor talks in the automotive industry is vital to both sides.

Our View -- Big 3, UAW at a crossroads


The Free Press

What may be the most important showdown for the future of labor and U.S. automakers is developing.

The Big Three — GM, Ford and Chrysler — are approaching the coming contract talks with their sights set on deep concessions from the United Auto Workers. If they don’t get them, there are less-than-veiled threats to move operations overseas.

Labor, through UAW President Ron Gettelfinger, has said his members shouldn’t bear all the sacrifice as Detroit restructures.

From management’s side, the sticking point is the high cost of labor. They say there is a $30-an-hour disadvantage against Toyota and Honda.

While salaries are about the same, management says the added cost is due to generous health-care and pension plans for hundreds of thousands of union retirees and their dependents.

In the past, this sort of saber rattling before negotiations was to be expected. But after years of concessions and cuts, the gulf is still wide and the most difficult fix has yet to be accomplished.

The union so far has approved cuts for retirees and the Big Three have cut about 70,000 UAW jobs. But the costs of wages with benefits, management argues, still puts them at a competitive disadvantage with Japanese automakers and Detroit cannot rebound unless that gap can be closed — one auto executive told The Wall Street Journal by “80 percent.”

Labor, on the other hand, has said automakers need to concentrate on putting out vehicles that meet consumer demands quicker. A task that would require widespread retooling of auto manufacturing that exists today.

If analysts are to be believed, it would appear the UAW would be open to trimming more, such as outsourcing some work and limiting the time unemployed UAW workers can stay in the “job bank” — where idled workers await recall while still receiving close to full salary. That may not be enough.

The forecast for health-care costs makes this a make-or-break item. Reports are surfacing that rising health costs could add another $15 to the wage-and-benefit gap. But for the union, they are worried about their numbers. Twenty years ago, there were about 1 million UAW members. Now with buyouts and early retirements they could dip to fewer than 500,000. They are not as likely to agree to more job cuts to narrow the cost gap.

There are two possible options being discussed to reducing the health-care costs. One is for the government to take over some of the burden. This isn’t likely since the White House has already rebuffed automaker requests for tax and other economic concessions.

The other — and what some analysts are saying is more likely — is the Big Three combining their retiree health-care obligation into a trust that would be partially funded by them but managed by the UAW. Such a deal was struck with Goodyear and its retirees. That deal, however, did not have large obligations to absorb as do the auto workers.

There would still need to be some big concessions to pull this off, both from automakers that would have to pour in billions of dollars and the union that would have to provide caps and limited liabilities. But clearly something very creative needs to emerge from these negotiations to prevent even more job losses in the U.S. and possibly even fewer — if any — cars made in America.



print this story    email this story   

Click here to load this Caspio Bridge DataPage.
Click here to load this Caspio Bridge DataPage.




monster
wheels

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Top Jobs

Manufacturing Positions - LeSueur Inc.
Manufacturing Positions

Le Sueur Incorporated is a thriving, full service foundry and die-cast business produ
...>MORE

LIVINGLINKS
livinglinks.org

Part-Time Family Support Specialists
...>MORE

MANKATO CLINIC
It's All About Caring
MankatoClinicJobs

Ti
...>MORE

Alumacraft Boat Co. Job Opening
Alumacraft Boat Co. Job Opening
www.alumacraft.com
<
...>MORE

See all ads

Top Auto/Recreation

Lager's Chrysler World •Mankato
LagersChryslerWorld
Browse South Central Minnes
...>MORE

See all ads

Top Real Estate/Rental

APARTMENTS & TOWNHOMES
The best selection. Lloyd Management, Inc. Where you're not just residents, you're family! 507-625-5573
>MORE

For Sale By Owner
Newer rambler w/ 2 otbldgs. 9.67 acres.. Basement finished w/ mthr-in-law apt. $319,000. 507-380-4503
...>MORE

CENTURY 21 ATWOOD REALTY, INC.
AtwoodRealtyOnline

712 8th Street
Nicollet
...>MORE

FSBO - 18 Cardianl Court North Mankato
Pre Realtor Price of $359,900 SAVE $15,000
5BR, 3BA, 4200+sf Huge kitchen w/ hrdwd flrs, private master ste. Fenced
...>MORE

See all ads

Top Deals of the Day

PUREBRED GOLDEN RETRIEVERS
5 M's and 2 F's, shots, dews, vet chk¹d
papers, $400 507-461-2396
...>MORE

The Free Press Classified Marketplace
Place your Top Deal of the Day
Contact Roxanne or Lee today!
classified@mankatofreepress.com
507-
...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index