The Free Press, Mankato, MN


February 20, 2014

Our View: Measure the charter schools

Why It Matters: A legislative proposal would heighten test score scrutiny on charter schools in Minnesota.

The battery of exams that confront Minnesota students annually are known as “high-stakes tests” for a reason: Low scores have consequences both for students and for school districts.

A legislative proposal would turn up the consequences for Minnesota’s charter schools. A bill offered by Sen. Terri Bonoff, DFL-Minnetonka, would require charter school authorizers — the sponsors — to offer a defense for those schools whose test scores consistently rank in the bottom quarter of the state rankings.

Bonoff’s proposal would not force a low-ranking school to shut down, but she makes no bones about it: She thinks many of them should close.

Three charter schools in the Mankato area are among those who fall short on Bonoff’s criteria: Lafayette Public Charter School, Minnesota New Country School in Henderson and RiverBend Academy in Mankato. Not surprisingly, those schools and their supporters disagree with the notion that they should get extra scrutiny based on test scores. “We were never opened to try and pass standardized tests,” protests a teacher at Minnesota New Country in a recent Free Press story.

Reliance on standardized testing to measure academic achievement, be it by student or school, will always have detractors. But there is no reasonable dispute that, given the vast amounts of public resources expended on education, we need to know what we’re getting for our money.

And yardsticks are particularly valuable with charter schools, which are liberated from many requirements that constrain the majority of public schools and are intended to be innovative. What’s working? And, just as important, what isn’t? Innovation itself is not the goal; improvement is, and innovations are not always improvements.

Standardized tests may not be the perfect measurement, but there is a political and practical consensus that they’re the best tool we have for the task. Critics may complain about “teaching to the test,” but if — and it’s a big if — the test accurately measures what we expect students to have mastered, teaching to it is a laudable approach.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • Spear column: Hoffner case tested first and right rules The biggest news stories carry the biggest risk

    April 20, 2014

  • SCC leads the way on work ed The importance of higher education has never been more pronounced than with the changes occurring in our economy, especially in manufacturing. Bloomberg News noted that manufacturing accounts for 80 percent of our exports and for every one high-tech

    April 20, 2014

  • Our View: Y helps kids with skatepark Thumbs up to the YMCA and supporters working quickly to open an interim roller sport park. When fire destroyed Chesley Roller Sports Park in February, the Y made the commitment to rebuild it this summer and fall. But the Y also moved to give skateboa

    April 19, 2014

  • Our View: Make course evaluations public There's been a considerable and legitimate debate over the years about whether students at a public university should have access to teacher and course evaluations. Whenever there is a legitimate debate, it's hard to be in favor of less information a

    April 18, 2014

  • Our View: Drawing the line after Ukraine Why it matters: Tensions are ramping up once more as Russia tries to dictate to Ukraine.

    April 17, 2014

  • Our View: Costs key in health care access While more uninsured got coverage, costs must be controlled to sustain programs

    April 16, 2014

  • Our View: Saving lives trumps booking drug users Changes to the drug laws would save lives of those who overdose

    April 15, 2014

  • Pay attention! Distraction a problem A few years ago safety experts focused heavily on the dangers of people talking on cellphones while driving. Some states passed laws prohibiting the use of hand-held phones in cars as a result. Today much attention is on motorists typing on tiny hand

    April 14, 2014

  • DEBATE MEDICAL MARIJUANA When Minnesota lawmakers return from their spring break, one of the issues they may face is medical marijuana. This has been kicked around too many times. We feel it deserves to be pushed from committee and debated on the floor. The issue has been tr

    April 13, 2014

  • Our View: Cities saved on garbage collection Mankato and North Mankato saved their taxpayers money by bidding on garbage service

    April 12, 2014