The Free Press, Mankato, MN

Editorials

January 8, 2014

Youth offenders deserve chance

Why it matters: A new law that keeps juvenile offenses off some public records must be balanced with public's right to know

When it comes to the public’s safety, it’s hard to argue for secrecy, but a recent compromise law strikes a good balance between the public’s right to know and a young person’s shot at a second chance.

The law that was scheduled to take effect Jan. 1 limits the availability of some juvenile crime records from easy electronic availability. Most of the juvenile records that were once widely available online (felony cases for those 16 and older) are now only available in hard copy form at the local courthouses.

The records were previously widely available with searches of the Internet or court databases.

Lawmakers came to together to modify the law in part to give juvenile offenders a chance to distance themselves from their past and make a new start with a job or education.

The records and documents of cases where juveniles are charged with more serious violent crimes will still be available electronically.

But most of the other felony level crimes will only be available at the courthouse.

Minnesota is one of the few states that make this information available on juveniles at the stage of charging, before they have been convicted.

Proponents of the law’s new restrictions argue that an employer might look at the records and only see the charges, but not the whole case which could have ended in a not guilty verdict.

The state Juvenile Delinquency Rules Committee has petitioned the Minnesota Supreme Court to reject the new rules mostly because they will put an added burden on the court system. Courts will have to do more paperwork and continually update cases to determine their public status.

The committee also is suggesting the Legislature somehow overstepped its bounds in changing access to records, arguing it is the responsibility of the courts. There is a hearing on the matter scheduled for Feb. 18.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Editorials