The Free Press, Mankato, MN

August 27, 2013

Sports drinks no substitute for water and wholesome foods

By April Graff
Hy-Vee Registered Dietitian

---- — Q: Are sports drinks OK for my young son? He is very active in sports and I’m worried about him getting dehydrated.

A: If your son is involved in a vigorous physical activity that lasts longer than one hour, a sports drink can be beneficial. Drinks such as Gatorade and PowerAde provide fluid and electrolytes (sodium, potassium, chloride) lost through sweat during prolonged exercise. The key words here are “vigorous” exercise and “longer than one hour.” While some sports drinks are sugar-free, most contain carbohydrates in the form of liquid sugar and/or high-fructose corn syrup to provide energy for working muscles.

While sports drinks may help hydrate your son during a long soccer match, they’re not necessary. Kids can get all the nutrients and hydration they need by eating healthy foods and drinking water before, during and after exercise. Foods like fruit, yogurt and whole grains are all great choices. If you decide to let your son have a sports drink during or after prolonged exercise, limit him to an eight-ounce serving. Kids shouldn’t drink more than eight ounces of any sugary drink, even if they are very active.

Kids should not consume sports drinks with meals or just because they’re thirsty. One of the biggest concerns is that if sports drinks replace good sources of calcium in the diet, such as milk or soy beverages, kids won’t get the calcium and vitamin D their bones needed during rapid growth. Also, kids should learn to enjoy pure water and not need to have a sweetened drink. The more sweet someone tastes, the more sweet the person wants, leading to a never-ending cycle.

Sports drinks contain calories, too, and can increase the risk of excess weight gain — which can be a problem for sedentary kids. Guzzling sports drinks outside of exercise will also boost a child’s intake of sodium and refined sugar. Prolonged consumption has also been linked to tooth erosion.

Bottom line: If your son is a sports drink fan, reserve them for prolonged exercise and keep his portion size to eight ounces. Instead, encourage water and wholesome foods.