The Free Press, Mankato, MN

Your View

August 25, 2013

Health reform will be more costly than Medicare

Cost skyrocketed with health care corporatization

In a letter published July 25, Ron Yezzi argued in response to Al DeKruif that it was OK for one family of two to pay 32 percent of its income for health insurance since there were some couples who would only pay 20 percent, and in addition they would enjoy the benefits of guaranteed and universal coverage and other benefits without any additional cost.

Let us pause for reflection, lest Socrates be right that none of us know anything. The cost of this plan is too high for everyone including those who would receive a subsidy from the government to buy insurance.

The Affordable Care Act does not reform anything about the payment for health care that makes it affordable, and actually adds to the cost by complicating the methods of payment and requiring expensive oversight and enforcement to make it happen.

We currently experience expenses of 40 percent or more of our health care dollar to handle the financial paperwork of privately insured care. This includes the profits and expenses of insurance companies/HMO’s plus the expenses of providers to collect the revenues they have earned. This diversion of the health care dollar stands to become worse, not better under the ACA.

The plan alleges controls on the cost of insurance by requiring a return of 80 percent of premiums to benefits and creating a competitive environment at the health insurance exchanges. Why do we need that kind of a hit when the Medicare plan accomplishes the same thing for 3 to 4 percent and other developed countries provide health care for 1 to 12 percent of GDP? We are at 16 percent and aimed at about 23 percent of GDP.

Another way to understand the problem is that the ACA does not address the new reality of the corporate dominance of health care which has occurred since about 1980. Big Business derisively referred to health care as a cottage industry ripe for a takeover, and they did it. Health care has become a large industrial group on Wall Street.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Your View