The Free Press, Mankato, MN


October 6, 2012

Cross: Hunters aren’t biggest threat to pheasants

— When Minnesota’s pheasant hunting season opened last October, it was on a decidedly pessimistic note after a severe winter followed by a cold, wet spring decimated bird numbers.

But Saturday’s Minnesota pheasant opener will be greeted with at least a small measure of optimism after roadside surveys indicated a 68 percent increase in birds over 2011 numbers.

And really, it couldn’t have gotten much worse, could it?

Well, yes, actually it could have. A lot worse.

Try having no pheasant hunting season at all.

It happened in 1969.

After a particularly severe winter of 1968-69, Minnesota’s pheasant spring breeding population had fallen to about a third of 1968 levels.

Bowing to public and political pressure over concerns that hunting would further decimate pheasant numbers, a decision was reached to close the 1969 pheasant hunting season entirely in Minnesota.

“Give ’em a break and let them rebuild their numbers,” was the reasoning in spite of wildlife biologists’ admonitions that stockpiling pheasants wouldn’t work.

A spring roadside survey conducted by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources the following spring indeed revealed a significant jump in pheasant numbers.

However, in Iowa where bird populations also had suffered a similar precipitous decline but where the hunting season still took place, bird numbers increased at the same level.

So rather than letting pheasant numbers rebound, the only thing closing Minnesota’s 1969 pheasant season really did was deprive state hunters of hours of outdoor recreation.

And, of course, allow state wildlife biologists to say, “See, we told you so.”

Further proof of the inability to stockpile the game birds was underscored again just a few years later when in 1972, a sportsmen’s club in Douglas County in West Central Minnesota managed to get the state to go along with a study that would close the entire county to pheasant hunting from 1973 to 1975.

In lieu of a hunting season, about 5,000 pen-raised pheasants were released throughout the county at a density of about 7.7 birds/square mile each year.

In surrounding counties where hunting continued, bird stocking was done at a far smaller rate of .6 pheasants/square mile annually.

A logical conclusion would be that with no hunting and more stocking, Douglas County should be awash in birds.

The reality was there was virtually no difference in bird numbers, hunted or not.

Fortunately, since 1970 when pheasant hunting resumed with an abbreviated, 16-day season, there have been no more closed pheasant hunting seasons in Minnesota.

In fact, over the years, the season has been expanded considerably; the 2012 season will run for 81 days — Oct. 13-Jan. 1, 2013.

And in spite of the longer season, pheasants are doing about as fine as can be expected.

Most would now agree that rather than hunting, the most critical factor to pheasant populations is the quantity and quality of habitat and to a lesser degree, the weather.

Since 1986, a key component to pheasant populations in Minnesota and elsewhere has been the Conservation Reserve Program.

The amount of CRP acres in Minnesota has varied in the past but it has ranged as high as 1.7 million acres since the first contracts were signed in 1986.

That figure has been in a downhill slide in recent years.

On Sept. 30 alone, contracts for nearly 300,000 acres of CRP expired. What’s more, contracts on another 300,000 acres of CRP will be expiring over the next three years.

High commodity prices are driving up land values and rents to levels that even the most altruistic, conservation-minded farmers find difficult to resist.

And it doesn’t help that Congress has been unable to get its act together in crafting a new farm bill.

So the future of the immensely popular program that has been a boon to conservation and wildlife remains clouded and uncertain.

In the meantime, at least when compared to last year, bird numbers are up a bit.

In fact, the DNR is predicting we’ll harvest about 290,000 roosters this fall, up from the 204,000 birds taken in 2011.

That’s far short of the magical million-bird mark that Minnesota pheasant hunters routinely achieved in the best days of pheasant hunting during the ’40s, ’50s and even into the ’60s.

But it’s a heck of a lot better than none at all.

John Cross is a Free Press staff writer. Contact him at 344-6376 or by e-mail at

Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • mfp sports jcross outdoor column 7-20 Chasing walleyes in South Dakota nice We slowed to a crawl the other day on the dusty Day County township road in northeast South Dakota, a courtesy to the farmer who was baling ditch hay south of Webster.Otherwise, we would have enveloped him as he drove his open tractor in the choking

    July 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Fishing report Outlook on area lakes

    July 6, 2014

  • Cross column: No wake, no fish ... no problems on the water Patience is always a virtue when fishing.

    July 6, 2014

  • Cross column: Where does the buck stop in your home?

    Displaying your trophy catch can be debatable

    June 29, 2014

  • Know Your Lakes: Series maps

    Missed out on the weekly lake preview Wednesday's in the print edition? That's ok, we have you covered here. View the series thus far and download a printable PDF.

    May 24, 2011

  • Storms came at horrible time for pheasants For pheasants and pheasant hunters, there were no silver linings to be found in the storm clouds that inundated the countryside with heavy rains this week.A foot of rain falling in just a week is never good, but for pheasants, it came at precisely th

    June 22, 2014

  • Early morning is beautifully lonely Benjamin Franklin was on to something when he extolled the benefits of "early to bed, early to rise." While I can't vouch for its effect on health, wealth or wisdom, rolling out of the sack certainly seems to pay dividends for outdoor activities. The

    June 15, 2014

  • mfp sports cross column 6-1 Cross: Take a kid fishing, no license needed A few years ago, while cruising with a co-worker through an area community on a steamy summer day, we passed a vacant lot. There, oblivious to the heat and humidity, a group of kids were playing a game of pick-up baseball, racing down well-worn paths

    June 2, 2014 1 Photo

  • Cross: Once upon a time, when fishing was simple... Once upon a time, fishing was a pretty simple affair. A rod-and-reel, some bait and tackle, perhaps a rowboat if you were lucky, and you were in business. While the basic premise of angling -- to catch fish -- remains, it sure seems to have grown mor

    May 25, 2014

  • mfp sports jcross opening day 2 Almost too nice to catch Leech Lake walleye LEECH LAKE -- Opening day of the Minnesota fishing season on Leech Lake arrived Saturday, cloudless and with nary a breath of wind. It was the nice weather one might expect all winter-weary anglers to embrace as we motored away from harbors, resorts

    May 11, 2014 2 Photos