The Free Press, Mankato, MN

State, national news

March 26, 2013

Kennedy questions whether top court should rule on gay marriage

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court Tuesday raised the prospect that it will decline to say whether the Constitution gives gays the right to marry, in an argument that revealed a chasm among the justices on one of the country's most divisive issues.

A decision to back out of the case would be an anticlimax to a clash billed as potentially the biggest civil-rights dispute in decades. It would let same-sex marriage resume in California, without directly affecting the rest of the country.

Justice Anthony Kennedy, often the court's swing vote, twice asked whether the most prudent course would be not to rule in the case, which centers on California's Proposition 8, a voter-approved ban on gay marriage. He said the case was taking the court into "uncharted waters."

"I just wonder if the case was properly granted," Kennedy said during the 80-minute session Tuesday in Washington. He suggested the appeals court decision striking down Proposition 8 was too narrow to warrant a high court ruling on the sweeping questions in the case.

The argument comes as public support for gay marriage hits record levels. Nine states and the District of Columbia now let gay couples marry. President Barack Obama backs same-sex marriage, and his top Supreme Court lawyer urged the court to overturn Proposition 8.

The high court has a spectrum of options. It could reinstate California's ban, known as Proposition 8, and leave each state to make its own decision about letting gays marry. It could issue a narrow ruling that would create a right to gay marriage in California and perhaps a handful of other states. Or it could announce a constitutional right to gay marriage nationwide.

The court could also sidestep the marriage issue by ruling on procedural grounds. The justices spent about 20 minutes today debating whether the supporters of Proposition 8 have "standing" to defend it on appeal. A ruling that they don't would reinstate a trial judge's decision declaring Proposition 8 to be unconstitutional.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
State, national news
  • Bills aim to improve English language instruction English language learners integrated into mainstream classrooms

    April 24, 2014

  • Allina drops celebrated birthing option MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Allina Health has pulled the drain plug on a celebrated birthing option at its 11 Minnesota hospitals and the Mother Baby Center in Minneapolis. Allina says it will no longer offer water births because of new guidance from the Ame

    April 24, 2014

  • Federal study finds mercury in trout caught in three Grand Canyon creeks PHOENIX — With their natural beauty and protected environments, the Grand Canyon and other national parks in the West would seem removed from having mercury in their streams and rivers. But a federal study found small levels of the contaminant in ra

    April 24, 2014

  • Post office sales fight grows SAN FRANCISCO — The Advisory Council on Historic Preservation has issued a report to Congress that criticizes the U.S. Postal Service’s disposal of historic properties and calls for a suspension of all sales until a host of recommendations are implem

    April 24, 2014

  • Lawmakers jockey over budget surpluses WASHINGTON — Less than 24 hours after the University of Kentucky men’s basketball team beat cross-state rival Louisville to advance to the Sweet 16, Lexington Mayor Jim Gray asked state lawmakers for $80 million to renovate Rupp Arena, the iconic bui

    April 23, 2014

  • Minn. lawmakers seek to enhance privacy protection ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Minnesota lawmakers are on the verge of cracking down on public employees who abuse their access to citizen data. A measure being negotiated in a House-Senate conference committee would do more to expose and punish data snoope

    April 23, 2014

  • Republican activists push party on gay marriage LAS VEGAS (AP) — As bans against gay marriage crumble and public opinion on the issue shifts rapidly, some Republicans are pushing the party to drop its opposition to same-sex unions, part of a broader campaign to get the GOP to appeal to younger vot

    April 23, 2014

  • mfp church abuse Archbishop deposition on abuse made public Archbishop John Nienstedt says no one reprimanded who handled abuse

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Legislature takes aim at new lottery games Legislators angry lottery didn't tell of new games

    April 22, 2014

  • NE ski resort extends season Lutsen still has two to four feet of snow on its runs

    April 22, 2014

Press-Plus Subscribe
Sign In
Featured Ads
AP Video