The Free Press, Mankato, MN

State, national news

November 30, 2012

Update: County attorney won't appeal ruling in coach's child porn case

MANKATO — A judge has dismissed child pornography charges against Minnesota State University¹s head football coach saying videos he made of his children dancing naked were innocent and protected by the First and 14th Amendments to the Constitution.

Complete ruling here.

Charges of creating and possessing child pornography were filed against Todd Hoffner, 46, in August after MSU officials found videos on his university-issued cellphone when he turned it in for repair. Assistant Blue Earth County Attorney Mike Hanson said two videos found on the phone showed one of Hoffner¹s children masturbating and all three of them, a son and two daughters between the ages of 5 and 9, performing a lewd skit.

After watching the videos and completing a "painstaking review" of reports completed by a Blue Earth County social worker, who did her own investigation and concluded Hoffner¹s children hadn¹t been sexually abused, District Court Judge Krista Jass granted Hoffner¹s motion to dismiss the charges for lack of probable cause.

Jass said it was clear in the video that the children were not being lewd, Hoffner did not know what type of skit they were going to perform when they asked him to make a video and that Hoffner wasn¹t directing the children in any way.

"In fact, none of the children¹s actions are age-inappropriate," Jass said in an order, which included a 25-page memorandum explaining the order, released Friday afternoon. "They acted as any child, acutely aware of his/her nakedness, would act -- playful and silly.

"Moreover, (Hanson) has not presented any evidence tending to show that (Hoffner) recorded his children in furtherance of his own prurient sexual interests or because he intended to distribute the videos outside the home to pedophiles."

In a written news release, Assistant Blue Earth County Attorney Mike Hanson said he does not plan to appeal the ruling. He also said he doesn¹t plan to comment on the case beyond what was in his release.

"Our office was trying to enforce a statute enacted to protect children," Hanson¹s release said. "No matter what the prosecutor does in a controversial case with a high-profile suspect, they will be criticized. We do not go looking for cases like this, they are brought to us.

"While we do not agree with (Jass') decision to dismiss the case, we accept it. Enough media attention has been devoted to this case and we do not plan to make any further comment."

Hoffner will remain on leave from his coaching position for now, said Dan Benson, MSU director of media relations. Despite the disruption caused by Hoffner being placed on paid leave before the season started, the university¹s football team is 12-0 and will host the national quarterfinals Saturday.

"There is no change in his status," Benson said. "There is a pending university investigation, so we can¹t comment further."

A press conference for Hoffner was scheduled for 4 p.m. Friday at Maschka, Riedy & Ries, the law firm representing Hoffner.

Shortly after Hoffner was arrested at his home in Eagle Lake and charged, his wife, Melodee, made a public statement saying she supported him. As a high school counselor, she said she was confident her children hadn¹t been mistreated and her husband hadn¹t done anything wrong.

"I hope someone with authority will take a new look at this and see it for what it is," she said during a news conference in August.

There were meetings between Hoffner¹s attorney, Jim Fleming, Blue Earth County Attorney Ross Arneson and Hanson after Blue Earth County Human Services completed an investigation with the Hoffner children and found no evidence of sexual abuse. Arneson and Hanson still declined to dismiss the charges, saying a jury should decide if the videos contained child pornography.

Jass' ruling dismisses the charges without a trial.

She noted in her memorandum that any concern Hanson had that a pedophile could obtain the videos and use them for sexual stimulation was genuine. "But the fact that a pedophile may find the images sexually appealing or arousing does not make the images pornographic."

She also made it clear that she understands parents have varying opinions about child nudity. But Jass also said what happens in a private home is not the government's business. Federal court rulings have said that child nudity is protected free speech as long as the nudity isn¹t pornographic or obscene.

"For some parents, allowing a child to run around naked at home is perfectly natural, an expression of freedom that represents the spirit of childhood," Jass said in her memorandum. "But for others, unclad bodies are a source of discomfort, an affront to civility and a potentially dangerous attraction for pedophiles. These clashing sensibilities can create conflict, even when the nudity in question takes place at home. Absent harm to the children, it is not for the state to take a position on these divergent viewpoints, but to preserve the fundamental privacy interests of the family.

"So long as the children remain unharmed and the parents have no intent to exploit or depict their children in an overtly lewd or sexualized manner, the First and Fourteenth Amendments guarantee parents the right to photograph or video record their children in a state of nudity without fear of criminal prosecution."

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
State, national news
  • Cinema verite documentarian Robert Drew dies at 90 Filmmaker Robert Drew, a pioneer of the modern documentary who in "Primary" and other movies mastered the intimate, spontaneous style known as cinema verite and schooled a generation of influential directors that included D.A. Pennebaker and Albert M

    July 30, 2014

  • Homeowner killed, another injured in Vegas crime spree LAS VEGAS — A horrific carjacking and home invasion spree ended with two people dead and a woman in critical condition. One victim, Richard Ramos, a 59-year-old father of four, “fought to his death” to protect his wife and children from their attack

    July 30, 2014

  • Officer Shooting Minnesota-9 [Duplicate] UPDATE: Suspect in Minnesota officer killing in custody WEST ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Police in Minnesota say a man wanted in the shooting death of an officer is in custody after being shot by police. St. Paul police spokesman Sgt. Paul Paulos says 39-year-old Brian Fitch Sr. got out of a minivan firing at

    July 30, 2014 4 Photos

  • Officer Shooting Minnesota-3 [Duplicate] Minnesota officer killed making traffic stop WEST ST. PAUL (AP) — A police officer in Minnesota was fatally shot Wednesday while making a traffic stop and authorities said they were searching for a suspect. Mendota Heights police officer Scott Patrick, 47, was shot about 12:20 p.m. after pulli

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • Possible suspect caught in Minnesota cop shooting WEST ST. PAUL (AP) — A potential suspect in the shooting of a police officer in Minnesota has been captured. Minnesota Public Radio News reports that the officer was killed. Television news footage showed the man being pulled from his vehicle Wednes

    July 30, 2014

  • Police shooting reported in West St. Paul WEST ST. PAUL (AP) — Police are responding to the reported shooting of an officer in West St. Paul. Details weren't immediately available. Calls from The Associated Press to several police and city departments in the area weren't immediately returne

    July 30, 2014

  • Mars rover Opportunity breaks the off-world driving record Opportunity, the little rover that could, has broken a 41-year-old driving distance record that’s out of this world. The decade-old NASA Mars rover has crossed the 25-mile mark, surpassing the 24.2-mile record held by the Russian moon rover Lunokhod

    July 30, 2014

  • Minnesota officials consider high-speed rail ROCHESTER, Minn. (AP) — Minnesota officials are holding public meetings on a proposed high-speed train linking Rochester to the Twin Cities. Transportation planners from state and federal departments are evaluating possibilities for the Zip Rail pas

    July 30, 2014

  • Study finds 5 servings of produce is enough, but we're not eating it How many times will we have to be told? Apparently we haven’t reached the point when we’ll change our habits, but here goes again: Eating five servings of fruits and vegetables every day can help us live longer. That comes from researchers’ analysis

    July 30, 2014

  • GOP gov hopeful Honour wants state spending cap Tells St. Cloud Times he wants a statutory budget cap linked to population and inflation.

    July 29, 2014